Home
Team
|
Result
|
Away
Team
|
Year
|
Normanton
|
7 - 2
|
Holbeck
|
1899
|
Normanton
|
5 - 0
|
Leeds
|
1900
|
Birkenhead
Wanderers
|
2 - 0
|
Millom
|
1901
|
Windhill
|
5 - 0
|
Millom
|
1902
|
Millom
|
7 - 8
|
Parton
|
1904
|
Featherstone
Rovers
|
23 - 2
|
Widnes
|
1906
|
Saville
Green
|
10 - 0
|
Bramley
|
1907
|
Whitehaven
Recreation
|
13 - 8
|
St Helens
|
1908
|
Beverley
|
7 - 2
|
Ebbw Vale
|
1909
|
Sharlston
Rovers
|
12 - 7
|
Workington Town (1st leg)
Lost 23-14 on aggregate
|
1946
|
Risehow
& Gillhead
|
10 - 2
|
Keighley (2nd leg) Lost 13
– 2 on aggregate
|
1948
|
Highfield
|
4 - 27
|
Beverley
|
1995
|
Highfield
|
20 - 35
|
West
Hull
|
1996
|
Chorley
|
12 - 27
|
Thatto
Heath
|
1996
|
West
Hull
|
10 - 6
|
York
|
1996
|
York
|
14 - 21
|
Dudley
Hill
|
1997
|
Bramley
|
10 - 16
|
Ellenborough
Rangers
|
1998
|
Doncaster
|
18 - 23
|
Featherstone
Lions
|
1998
|
Ellenborough
Rangers
|
14 - 12
|
Hunslet
|
1998
|
Egremont
|
18 - 0
|
Workington Town
|
1998
|
Bramley
|
12 - 18
|
Leigh
Miners Rangers
|
1999
|
Batley
|
0 - 10
|
Oldham
St Anne’s
|
2000
|
Sheffield Eagles
|
14 - 16
|
Thornhill
|
2000
|
Chorley
|
8 - 22
|
Woolston
|
2001
|
Wath
Brow Hornets
|
13 - 12
|
Workington Town
|
2003
|
Halton
Simms Cross
|
15 - 8
|
London Skolars
|
2003
|
Sharlston
Rovers
|
30 - 28
|
Dewsbury
|
2004
|
Dudley
Hill
|
16 - 14
|
Keighley
|
2004
|
Swinton
|
14 - 26
|
East
Hull
|
2004
|
Wath
Brow Hornets
|
32 - 30
|
Dewsbury
|
2005
|
Thornhill
|
16 - 12
|
Workington Town
|
2006
|
Wath
Brow Hornets
|
14 - 12
|
London Skolars
|
2009
|
Doncaster
|
0 - 26
|
Siddal
|
2010
|
Prior to WW1 the giant killers were junior clubs that beat senior Northern Union opposition. From 1995 on the giant killers were amateur clubs that beat professional outfits.